WPC Oy{$9} Is.sIN-)ityMP]ڶYVF^`iQ|& 1(0 P*&h"ghBHɖ egu2:. Cq%t;\8s_'&&陯%N~ G}2Ҵ~A/NO:Ff߈=;"Lg8BgLT0 -)NUfb~ 7MHM(Y tJmLHV8j_bI@BAo1)2Bz,O6sSdWϙm.YuP~!& ]He#e#.$_cW+7x ^÷K\ g@3[wnPG9 PEd2UJ[%|{:#+##IBr:#U4a^ w4 mHP LaserJet 5L PCL,,88,,0(9 Z6Times New Roman RegularX(0q$USUS., X2Y Z&AmerType Md BT . ZSerifa BT /* g/*OMMLAW2tc3|xU q!USUS., X  L JXXL9JJL ErinBrockovich#L JJL9j##X;XJL K#Ԁ and . XX;. ACivilAction#. ##X;X. #   T Eachofthesemoviesisaboutacivilactionbyagroupofindividualsagainstlarge,wealthy l businesseswhoallegedlypollutedtheenvironment,totheseveredetrimentoftheplaintiffs(or X theirfamilymembers)health.Inboth,lawyersortheirassistants,playaprominentrolein D  movingthecaseforward.Sometimesthelawyersorassistantsactionsseemtobecontraryto 0  theirclientsbestinterestsortheirclientsspecificinstructions.  l  T Whether justiceistrulydoneineithercaseisnotparticularlyimportant.Bothcases  D terminatewithoutacourtjudgment.(InACivilActionajudgmentislaterenteredthatisstated  0  inthe subsequenthistoryprintedattheendbuttheoriginalplaintiffsarenotpartiestothat   case.).    T Inbothmovies,thelawyersagreetorepresenttheplaintiffsona contingentfeebasis,   whichmeansiftheplaintiffslose,thelawyersreceivenofees.Amongtheoftenheardcriticisms |  oflawyers,onehears:theymaketoomuchmoney;theypreyonthesufferingofpeoplefortheir h ownpersonalbenefit;contingentfees robtheinjuredplaintiffofatoolargeportionofthe T judgment;lawyerspromotelitigationsotheycanmakemoney,notforthebenefitoftheclient. @ Onecouldgoon. ,|  T Thewritingassignmentrelatingtothesetwomovieshastwoparts,oneabouttheroleof T attorneys,oneabouttheresolutionoflegalcontroversies outsideofcourt.Whetherthe @ plaintiffsordefendantsreceived justiceisnotreallyrelevanttoeitherpart. ,  T Inthedepictedcases,what proactiverolesdotheattorneysortheirassistantsplayin  movingthecaseforward?Arethoseconsistentwithwhatalawyer shoulddoinrepresenting  herorhisclients?Arethoseactionsintended(bytheactingpersons)tobenefitthemselvesor  theirclients?Ifoneweretoviewthoseactionsfromtheviewpointofanoutsidepersonwitha x lessthansympatheticopinionaboutlawyers,whatmightthatpersonconcludeaboutmotivations? d  T Whatarethefundamentalreasonsbehindthefactthatneithercaseproceededthrougha